Dr. Patricia McConnell Ventures into Fiction with Debut Mystery Novel ‘Away to Me,’ Set in the Canine World

Internationally renowned applied animal behaviorist and acclaimed non-fiction author, Dr. Patricia McConnell, is set to captivate readers with her first foray into the world of mystery novels, "Away to Me." The book, which immerses readers in the intricate and competitive realm of sheepdog trials, marks a significant literary transition for McConnell, known for her profound insights into human-animal relationships. Its anticipated release on February 24th has generated considerable interest among her long-standing fanbase and literary critics alike, particularly following a recent interview on "The Pawsitive Post in Conversation."

Dr. McConnell, celebrated for influential works such as "The Other End of the Leash" and the poignant memoir "The Education of Will," discussed her new novel with hosts Zazie Todd, PhD, and Kristi Benson. The conversation delved into the motivations behind her shift to fiction, the meticulous crafting of her characters—both human and canine—and the deliberate choices that shape her narrative, including a firm stance against canine fatalities within the plot.

A New Chapter: From Non-Fiction Authority to Mystery Novelist

For decades, Dr. Patricia McConnell has been a leading voice in animal behavior, bridging scientific understanding with practical application to foster deeper connections between pets and their human companions. Her non-fiction books have earned her a reputation for empathetic prose and insightful analysis, making complex behavioral concepts accessible to a broad audience. The transition to fiction, therefore, represents a new creative frontier, allowing McConnell to explore themes of loyalty, trust, and the intricate dynamics of the dog world through a narrative lens.

McConnell revealed that the idea for "Away to Me" originated from a vivid scene—a man being shot at a sheepdog trial—that "literally sort of cropped up like a piece of toast" in her mind. This initial spark, she explained, ignited a playful exploration into fiction writing, which soon evolved into a deeply engaging and challenging craft. She credits her collaboration with fellow author Cat Warren, known for "What the Dog Knows," as instrumental in her journey to master the nuances of fictional storytelling.

"Away to Me": Unraveling a Canine-Centric Mystery

"Away to Me" introduces readers to Maddie McGowan, an animal behaviorist in her mid-forties who lives on a secluded farm. Maddie, a complex character described by McConnell as initially "keeping things close to her vest," finds solace and purpose in her passion for sheepdog trials, where she competes as a hobbyist. Her household is a testament to her devotion to animals, featuring a smart yet "obnoxious" Border Collie named Jack, a protective sheep guarding dog, Bo Peep, and an elderly rescue terrier, Clementine. The narrative also sees her fostering a German Shepherd named Cisco, further enriching the canine tapestry of her life.

The plot thickens when a murder occurs at a sheepdog trial, drawing Maddie into an unfolding mystery. The novel is set against the backdrop of Maddie’s farm, which serves as a "safe house" following a difficult past in New Mexico, hinting at layers of unresolved personal history that contribute to her guarded nature. McConnell meticulously crafted Maddie’s character, describing the process as watching a "developing photograph" — richer, clearer, and more colorful with each written page. The intention was to create a protagonist whom readers would "fall in love with," a goal that the interviewers, Zazie Todd and Kristi Benson, confirmed was successfully achieved.

The "No Dog Dies" Mandate: A Reader-Centric Approach

One of the most notable and intentionally controversial aspects of "Away to Me" is Dr. McConnell’s firm decision that "no dog dies in the making of this novel." This policy, a direct response to a common reader aversion to animal suffering in fiction, was a point of discussion with her editor, who initially worried it might "give away the plot." However, McConnell defended her choice, arguing that it allows readers to engage with the story without the apprehension of canine tragedy.

This decision reflects a broader understanding of the unique emotional bond readers form with animal characters. While human characters may face peril or death, the loss of an animal, particularly a beloved dog, can be a deterrent for many readers. McConnell observed, "You can kill off the good guys, you can kill off the bad guys… but you cannot kill off a dog." This phenomenon speaks to the deep emotional investment and protective instincts many people feel towards dogs, extending even to fictional portrayals. The inclusion of this "spoiler" serves as an assurance to dog lovers, inviting them into a mystery where their beloved canine companions are safe.

The Art of Crafting Immersive Fiction

McConnell’s transition to fiction involved a rigorous commitment to the craft of writing. She acknowledged the inherent difficulties, noting that "it’s really easy to write bad fiction and really hard to write good fiction." Unlike non-fiction, where factual accuracy dictates the narrative, fiction offers boundless possibilities, yet demands precise choices in every sentence. Learning to write compelling dialogue, develop multifaceted characters, and construct an overarching plot with carefully placed "breadcrumbs" for a mystery were significant challenges.

To create an immersive experience, McConnell intentionally incorporated sensory details, particularly focusing on sound and scent. As a keen observer of the natural world, her descriptions of birdsong and the ambient sounds of the farm serve to transport the reader into Maddie’s environment. This deliberate use of sensory language, she explained, is crucial for "putting people there" and allowing them to become "immersed in a story," fulfilling the human need for narratives. The title itself, "Away to Me," a sheepdog command, doubles as a metaphor for Maddie’s internal conflict—her desire for connection warring with her need for solitude, echoing the solitary nature of owls on her "Lonely Owl Farm."

Themes of Friendship and the Promise of a Trilogy

Beyond the mystery, "Away to Me" deeply explores the theme of friendship, both human and canine. McConnell emphasized the importance of connections, stating, "what is more important than our connections, you know, than our connections to people?" While Maddie is initially solitary due to past trauma, the narrative highlights her profound bonds with her dogs, particularly Jack, who acts as one of her "best friends." She also has significant human friendships, including George, who tragically dies in the first chapter, and Dorothy, her "Border Collie girlfriend."

Excitingly for fans, "Away to Me" is planned as the first installment in a trilogy. The subsequent books will be titled "Come By" (another sheepdog command meaning to send a dog clockwise) and "That’ll Do" (a command for a dog to return, signifying work completion). McConnell confirmed that ongoing characters, such as the memorable Larry and Darryl and the other brother Darryl (based on real clients), will continue their roles, and new relationships, including "interesting men," are anticipated in "Come By." This serialization promises an enduring journey with Maddie and her canine companions, offering readers the "quasi-friendship" hit that long-running characters provide without the complexities of real-life relationships.

The Pawsitive Post Interview: Insights and Reception

The interview on "The Pawsitive Post in Conversation," accessible on YouTube and various podcast platforms, offered an intimate glimpse into McConnell’s creative process and the genesis of "Away to Me." Hosts Zazie Todd and Kristi Benson shared their enthusiasm for the novel, particularly its authentic portrayal of dog behavior and relationships. Benson lauded McConnell’s ability to depict a protagonist who could feel "exasperated with her dog" without the reader fearing mistreatment, a nuance vital for positive reinforcement trainers. This realism, McConnell noted, was crucial, as she aimed to present Maddie not as a "paragon of perfection" but as a relatable human figure.

The conversation also touched upon the inclusion of secondary "dog cases" within the plot, which serve to both develop Maddie’s character and provide readers with a window into the life of an animal behaviorist. McConnell explained that these cases, though fictionalized to protect privacy, are inspired by real-life client experiences, showcasing the often challenging and emotionally taxing realities of the profession, far removed from the "puppies and daisies" stereotype. The interview, conducted by peers who deeply understand the dog world and the craft of writing, underscored the novel’s authenticity and its potential to resonate deeply with its target audience.

Broader Implications for Animal Literature

Dr. Patricia McConnell’s venture into fiction holds significant implications for the genre of animal-centric literature and mystery novels. Her established credibility as an applied animal behaviorist brings an unparalleled level of authenticity to the portrayal of canine characters and their interactions with humans. This could elevate the standard for accuracy and psychological depth within dog-themed narratives, moving beyond superficial depictions.

Furthermore, her deliberate "no dog dies" policy taps into a growing market for "cozy mysteries" and stories that offer comfort and emotional safety, particularly concerning beloved animal companions. This approach caters to a segment of readers who seek engaging plots without the emotional distress of animal harm. By combining her expertise with a compelling mystery, McConnell is poised to not only entertain but also subtly educate readers on animal behavior and the profound bonds shared between humans and dogs, expanding the reach of her lifelong mission to improve these relationships.

As Dr. McConnell, at 77, embarks on this ambitious trilogy, her motivation remains clear: a profound love for writing and storytelling, coupled with the intellectual challenge of mastering a new craft. Her journey into fiction is a testament to the enduring power of creativity and the unwavering dedication to exploring the multifaceted world of human-animal connection. "Away to Me" promises to be a compelling read, offering both a gripping mystery and a heartfelt exploration of the lives we share with our canine friends.